By opening other locks you will find baseball cards and instructions. You will also need to find a 6 letter puzzle cryptex that is hidden.

The baseball cards are found in the hidden lock, the instructions are in the bottle lock, and the 6 letter puzzle cryptex is found in the pocket of the jacket in the closet.

The correct two teammates that are different with each characteristic are Fernando Tatis Jr. and Ivan Castillo.

On the back of the cards you will find 6 numbers that are highlighted. Using the instructions you convert those numbers into 6 letters and after descrambling the letters you will end up with “father”. Father will open the cryptex and inside you’ll find the first two digits of the phone number, 76.